[Opening shot: the exterior of a power plant at night time in Metropolis. Suddenly, a fighting cry is heard while two explosions erupt and sparks of blue electricity are seen jumping around the plant. It is under attack. A helicopter flies overhead at the scene, shining a spotlight. Cut to the interior; more of the blue electric sparks are seen as the helicopter shines where they came out. Cut to ground level of the spotlight, where the culprit behind the sparks’ feet clad in black thigh-high boots with spiked, medium-blue soles comes into the helicopter's spotlight as the camera tilts up from her feet to a medium full shot of her while she speaks. It is Livewire, who is attacking the power plant.]
LIVEWIRE: Give it up, Supergirl, can't you see the spotlight belongs to me?
Supergirl: Then I guess I better cut the power!
[She launches the air vent at her, but Livewire smirks as she is able to fly out of the way to dodge it. The impact sends rubble flying and almost hitting the nearby spectating workers, who exclaim as they cover their head to shield themselves from the rubble. Supergirl flies over to the workers to check on them.]
Supergirl: Are you guys okay?
[She gets zapped by Livewire from offscreen, sending her back and crashing and breaking off a cell tower, which hits the ground. Black dust clouds our view for a brief moment before it settles. Just then, Livewire zaps herself feet away from Supergirl, laughing. Supergirl grabs a steel beam, and with a battle cry, she whacks Livewire with it. This sends her crashing through a wooden utility pole, and into a tesla coil on a platform with four of them, followed by a said utility pole and a second one being dragged down with it falling down onto the platform and other electrical equipment, causing an explosion. As the smoke clears, Livewire lifts her head up, her eyes briefly swirling. Then, she suddenly notices electricity going from the tesla coil she crashed into toward her right hand. She puts that hand directly on the coil, which glows as she begins to power up!]
Livewire: (smirking) Ooh!
[Now getting an idea, LIvewire then puts her left hand on the other tesla coil, which also glows as she absorbs the electricity from it. She is now getting supercharged!]
LIVEWIRE: Ooh, am I amped up!
[Supergirl watches Livewire laugh boisterously as she levitates up into the air. Close-up of Livewire, her eyes glowing white.]
Livewire: Ready for a power surge, Supergirl?!
[Overhead shot of Supergirl, who looks surprised but keeps her guard up. Livewire then shoots herself into the air and disappears into the clouds. Supergirl looks up in confusion. Suddenly, Livewire blasts a huge jolt of electricity at Supergirl! It makes contact, causing the hero to scream. Soon, the screen goes to normal with the smoke clearing, and all that is left is a large smoking crater. The workers go over to the crater and look down into it, taking their hats off in mourning for the superheroine, believing she didn't survive. As the camera then pans to the right, Livewire zaps down to the ground and materializes, looking into the crater in surprise.]
[The camera zooms into the crater and the screen fades to black.]
[Later, we cut to a reporter announcing the news at the scene of the incident. In the middle of his report, Livewire is seen dancing and cheering for herself behind him.]
News Reporter: A grim scene here in Metropolis tonight… (Livewire: Whoo-hoo! Can you believe it? (laughs) Best day ever! Yeah!) ...as it appears, our own Superman Girl is… no more.
Livewire: (grabs microphone, and goes up into the camera) Seriously, ladies and gents. (camera zooms out to show her on TV in the Superhero Girls base) Call me the Krytonian Krusher, 'cause I just blasted Stupid-girl into obli-vi-on! (cut to the girls on the couch watching the news, devastated by it, believing Kara got killed) Whoo-hoo!
[Supergirl walks into view behind them, all burnt from the encounter. She opens the refrigerator and grabs a soda, as the reporter speaks.]
News reporter: The controversial figure, best known as the kid sister of beloved icon, Superman, was new to the city...
Babs: Oh, Kara, it can't be. (shakes her head) It just can't. (Diana puts her hand on her shoulder.)
News Reporter: (As he speaks, Kara gets a text from Clark (aka Superman) on her phone, which she pulls out. He asks, "U ded?". She replies, "no". Clark gives a "thumbs up", noting he's relieved to know his cousin is alright.) Her acts of heroism were always overshadowed by her emotional nature and hot temper.
[Frontal view of Kara; she puts her phone away while rolling her eyes. Back to her friends on the couch.]
Zee: How will we go on without them?
[Kara sits next to the girls, who doesn't notice her.]
Jessica: It's like I can feel their spirits with us, even now.
[Supergirl opens her soda, causing other girls to hear it and see Supergirl sitting next to them.]
Everyone: (hugs her, causing the couch to tilt) Supergirl!
Zee: You're alive!
Karen: You smell like fire!
Foreman: (on TV) And there she was, Mrs. Superman throwing turbine blades, crashing into stuff. Don't she know how expensive this power plant is?
[Cut to the girls.]
Kara: Ugh, can you believe I tried to save that jerk?!
Diana: Of course you tried to save that jerk. (Stands up with a close-up of her) You are Supergirl! (Pull back to show the girls) Now, sisters, let us go to the plant of power and correct this grievous misconception!
[Five-way split screen of the girls, except Kara, slide into view.]
Everyone: Yeah!
Kara: (o.s.) No!
[Record scratches when they hear Kara say that. They look at her as the scene cuts to Kara.]
Kara: They think Supergirl and the Silver Wolf bit the big one, right? (push-in on her) Kicked the bucket? Six feet under? Snuffed out? (Cut to Diana.)
Diana: Oh, no, they think you are dead.
Kara: Well, good, good. You know, 'cause every time Supergirl tries to help, all they see is chaos and destruction. (the girls sit back down) They're better off without her and… (stands up) You know what?! I am too!
Jessica: How could you say such a thing?
Kara: Don't you see? It's a clean slate! A fresh start! (medium close-shot) I get to decide what kind of hero I wanna be!
ZEE: Are you sure about this?
KARA: Never surer. Now what says "super teen"?
ZEE: Hmm... revoekam!
(Zee changes her)
KARA: Uh... no.
(Zee changes her)
KARA: (scoffs)
(Zee changes her)
KARA: Oh, I love it! No I don't.
(Zee changes her)
KARA: No.
(Zee changes her)
KARA: Nope.
(Zee changes her)
KARA: Now you're just making fun of me.
(Zee changes her)
KARA: Please, you don't even like this one.
(Zee keeps changing her while Kara keeps rejecting them)
KARA: Nope, No. No. Not happenin'. Come on, Zee, you're not even trying. Give me something new.
(She is given Power Girl's costume)
KARA: That's it! This is amazing!
ZEE: Yeah, I changed you from blue, red and yellow to blue, red and white.
KARA: And it's perfect! Thanks, Zee.
(cut to the other five on the couch)
KARA: Okay, got the new look. Now I need the new attitude. What's the number one thing you'd change about me?
BABS: Nope!
DIANA: I have no complaints whatsoever.
JESSICA: Not a whole lot.
ZEE: Not a thing. Nothing!
KARA: Dudes, I can take it. Karen, Karen. There must be something.
KAREN: Um, well, uh, perhaps sometime someone somewhere might have thought you had the teeniest... anger problem?
KARA: Thank you for your honesty, Karen. The new me appreciates it.
BABS: Oh, well, in that case... (pulls out giant list) Cool, huh? I got one for all of you! (clears throat) You're always late. You crack your knuckles. You drool when you sleep. You say things like "irregardless" and "supposebly". You mix up your "theirs", "there's", and "they'res", You're-
(Kara yanks her off the couch.)
KARA: You know, Babs, the old me would've struck oil with your head by now. But not me, no siree. The new me ain't gonna go there. T-H-E-I-R.
ZEE: What about Likable Lass? It's got excellent superhero alliteration.
KAREN: Uh, how about Power Girl?
DIANA: I still prefer Good Girl. You are good, and you are not a boy. Nothing could be more clear.
KAREN: Power Girl is pretty clear.
KARA: No, no, no, my new name's gotta have some oomph. Some kick. Some girl power. But not that.
KAREN: Like Power Girl?
BABS: Ugh, I still don't know what's wrong with Awesome Girl.
KARA: Wait! I got it!
(Montage of Kara rescuing people.)
REPORTER: That was incredible! Please, heroic stranger, tell us. Who are you?
KARA: Who am I? I'm Powergirl!
KAREN: I said that like ten times!
KARA: Ha ha, thank you. Thank you, yeah, I know I'm awesome.
SUPERMAN: Listen, cuz, you think from changing from yellow to white is gonna fool anyone? Pfft. This is just Supergirl in disguise!
(Everyone gasps)
KARA: Uh, actually, I am her, but... from an alternate universe! Yeah, yeah, it's just like Earth, but totally different. It's called, um, Earth-two! Yeah, yeah, that's it!
SUPERMAN: Earth-two, huh?
(beat)
SUPERMAN: Earth-two! Of course! Love it there! Way better than Earth-Five, am I right? What a dump!
KARA: Pfft, yeah, totally.
(the superhero girls cheer)
ZEE: Powergirl pulled it off! I just hope this new identity doesn't go to her head.
(montage of the new identity going to her head)
HELEN: So, before the break, you were saying that your powers are totally different from Supergirl's.
KARA: That's right, Helen. Supergirl famously had freeze breath. I, however, have frost air. Sort of an Earth-Two thing. Oh, and also, we say "supposeably" there.
(cheering)
HELEN: And on Earth-One, Supergirl used to be on a team. What about you, Powergirl? Will you be joining a team?
KARA: Oh, Helen. Teams are overrated. I mean, look at me. Awesome outfit, great name, best non-angry temperment ever. Powergirl's got it all. She doesn't need a team.
(Cut back to the Super Hero Girls watching on the couch, who are not pleased.)
ZEE: Anybody got any kryptonite?
KAREN: Guys, you gotta see this!
(Zee puts the book down on a table.)
KARA: "How I Did It: Destorying Supergirl; A Memoir". Yeah, so?
KAREN: So, this! "There I was partaking in some lighthearted mischief but Stupidgirl took it to a whole new level! Putting all those innocent lives in danger, Supergirl was a menace, and she needed to be taken down!"
KARA: WHAT?! Uh, I mean... whatever. Look, it doesn't matter. Supergirl's gone, and Powergirl's better anyway.
DIANA: LIES!
JESSICA: Supergirl was a hero. She didn't do what she did to be famous, she did it to help people, and she doesn't deserve to be treated this way!
KARA: The name's Powergirl. And I'm late.
(cheering)
LIVEWIRE: What up, Metropolis?
(She hits Powergirl and she goes flying, Kara gasps)
LIVEWIRE: Say hello to your new bestselling author! Sales are going great, but mama's hankering for a new set of wheels! I'm thinking something electric! So, time to write a new sequel, I'm talkin' to you, Powergirl!
KARA: (growls)
LIVEWIRE: So let's see if you're as easy to cook as that other blonde blockhead!
KARA: Oh no...
LIVEWIRE: Woo! The Kryptonian Krusher's two for two! Powergirl's just as much of a loser as Supergirl!
JESSICA: (in her head) Supergirl was a hero, she doesn't deserve to be treated this way.
LIVEWIRE: You know what? I kinda miss our dear departed Stupidgirl.
KARA: Hey, electrodweeb! The name's Supergirl!
LIVEWIRE: Supergirl?! What, how?!
(Kara appears on the other side, now dressed as Powergirl, she switches sides between dialogue dressed as Supergirl and Powergirl.)
KARA: Wouldn't you like to know, Live-whiner?
LIVEWIRE: How is this possible? I burned you both to a crisp.
KARA: Something about dying makes a girl think. Who cares about the haters? They don't know you. You know you. And on Earth-One, and on Earth-Two, I'm a hero!
(she punches out Livewire, who falls into the same hole Kara was in)
REPORTER: An extraordinary story unfolding tonight, at the grand opening of the Metropolis Power Plant, where the notorious supervillain Livewire was subdued by Supergirl and her Earth-two counterpart Powergirl, who, in a shocking development, announced she was returning home to quote, "spend more time with her friends".
KARA: And so, irregardless of my departure, I will leave you in good hands with the coolest superhero in any of the universes, the totally alive Supergirl! Also, her hair is awesome.
(cheering)
JESSICA: Good to have you back, Supergirl.
KARA: Thanks. Well, back to everyone hating me, I guess.
DIANA: Not everyone, Kara Zor-El.
(they all hug her)
ALL: Aw!
FOREMAN: I wanna say thanks to Supergirl... for leavin' us a giant mess! Come back, Powergirl! Don't leave us with this stupid-
(Kara chucks a table through the TV)
KARA: I do not have an anger problem, Karen!