Garth Bernstein interrupts the girls' lunch to ask for their help during an impending visit by Aquaman. He has been sending letters home to the hero in Atlantis, but has falsely claimed many accomplishments in hopes of impressing Aquaman enough to choose him as a sidekick. Kara organizes the rest of the girls, plus Oliver Queen and Hal Jordan, to make Garth's accounts appear true. She suits up to play the role of his arch-nemesis and lets him "defeat" her, but Aquaman takes the fight seriously and prepares to drag her back to Atlantis for imprisonment. The situation quickly degenerates into a fight between Kara (as Supergirl) and Aquaman; Garth breaks it up by admitting that he fabricated all his exploits. Aquaman confides that he will make Garth his sidekick someday, recognizing the efforts of Garth's friends to help him and seeing in him the potential for a true hero.
- Jessica McKenna as Garth Bernstein/Aqualad
- Will Friedle as Arthur Curry/Aquaman
- Grey Griffin as Diana Prince/Wonder Woman
- Tara Strong as Barbra Gordon/Batgirl
- Nicole Sullivan as Supergirl/Kara Danvers
- Kari Wahlgren as Zee Zatara/Zatanna
- Eddie Perino as Oliver Queen/Green Arrow
- This the first time since Retreat that we seen Garth in his Aqualad suit.
- In Sirens Conch Diana is revealed that have a terrible singing voice but during the Coral Reef song, Diana is shown to have a wonderful voice.
- It could be that she was lip-syncing the song.
|v • e Generation 2 animated media|